Wednesday, May 27, 2009

Wires Crossed


**** WARNING:  POTENTIAL SPOILERS! *******

I have to admit that the teaser trailer had me gripping since I first saw it.  

The last movie (Rise of the Machines) wasn't bad but it certainly showed that the Terminator lore had slipped in terms of film making and story telling.  So what about this movie?  The trailers certainly showed that the level of film making had been upped.  And though McG's reputation as a feature film director was still debatable, they did secure the services of one of Hollywood's bankable leading men in Christian Bale.  The only real question is what kind of story would they tell in a world where the paradox of time, and the history of three previous movies will be foremost in the minds of the viewing public.

The brunt of initial reviews for TERMINATOR: SALVATION basically say the same thing:  Lots of action wrapped around a clunky narrative.  On Tuesday evening I went to see things for myself and unfortunately, I am sad to report that those reviews are spot on.

As far as the thrilling action is concerned, I would have to give McG some props.  The combat staging is well-done as well as the overall desaturated, grayed out look of post judgement day Southern California.  What baffled me is how the character moments in this film where not only poorly edited, but lacked a cohesive point of view.  What's also interesting to me are the numerous missed opportunities to not only give the film some added depth, but to feel John Connor's struggle, and through his eyes.  (Not to mention a rather graphically limp ending)

Amazingly the John Connor in this film is largely unsympathetic.  He is indeed the leader of the fledgling resistance against Skynet but in this world (and due to the rifts in time from the previous films) they are questioning whether his status as the de facto leader is a prophecy or a fallacy.   This is something they barely touch on that could have fueled real conflict yet John goes about his ways in a rather routine and soldierly fashion.   He's basically become a droning military grunt whose apparently likable leadership qualities are lost on the audience.

What i'd really liked to have seen is John's rise within the resistance and his struggle to find a balance between fate and prophecy.  This is something that had only been described in the previous films and would have probably been more compelling to see.

And what about the ending?  All I can say is that after going out on a limb for two acts and still thinking this movie wasn't too bad, it took a turn for the worse.  It literally felt like the movie morphed into Resident Evil.  At least on that movie there where actual hordes of Zombies. Was it too much to ask to have more than 5 Terminators in the end battle?  After all this was Skynet??  The machines would have sicked every Terminator on our heroes but I guess they went on strike or on a union mandated smoke break or something.

So, see it for fun's sake but if I were you, i'd take my duckets and spend it on Star Trek instead.  


8 comments:

Javier said...

Did Louie just say the word duckets??? I thought i was the only one! Thanks for that review, i saw star trek thought it was cool, no biggie in my eyes. The russian kid(if he is russian) was a bit toooo much for me.

Emily said...

Haha, I made that decision this weekend - I saw Star Trek a second time rather than going to Terminator (and lately I rarely see a movie twice in theaters!)

Louie del Carmen said...

Javier,

Star Trek is well done in the sense that even with the re-boot, it stayed true to the Trek world. I have some film making gripes but the character pieces in it are strong. Anton Yelchin is Kyle Reese in Terminator: Salvation. I didn't mind him as Chekov and actually thought he was pretty effective.

I almost said "dubloons" but somehow, duckets seemed to sound better.

Emily,

I saw Trek twice, 2 days in a row. It actually held up the second time around. Overall a very
enjoyable film.

Senor Ira said...

Louie,

Based on the reviews and the director, I have passed on Terminator. But Lady J & I saw Trek twice (once on IMAX) and we loved it! Fun movie. It was a challenge to pull that movie off on many levels and they did it. Kudos to all involved.

We are eager to see "UP" this weekend.

blauereiter said...

Looking forward to Star Trek more than Terminator too myself, but I think I'll be catching both. :]

Louie del Carmen said...

Ira,

Agree with you on Trek. Nice casting job and great use of the characters. We're seeing UP this weekend with the kids. Ronnie is in town this weekend and we got to have dinner and hang out last night. He hopes everyone enjoys the film.

Yonghow,

T4 is a decent watch but make sure you see it before Trek.

Jason Scheier said...

I finally saw it..

Years ago I left the theater after watching Terminator 2 Judgment Day feeling filled with excitement, satisfaction, and most of all terminator.

This movie felt like a high budget T.V. Show Plot. After all these years of waiting for the next "Cinematic Chapter" for Terminator. This was a huge letdown. Not worth seeing in the theater, just watch it in HD at home.. :)

Gerald said...

Well said in your review. Star Trek is really worth it compared to Terminator: Salvation.